Best Mattress Protector: Shield Your Mattress from Spills, Dust, Wear, and Tear

Best Mattress Protector: Our Top Picks Reviewed in Detail

Below, we’ve reviewed the best mattress protectors to help you find the perfect fit for comfort and long-lasting mattress protection.

1. Brooklyn Bedding Luxury Cooling Mattress Protector – Best Mattress Protector Overall

Overview

Started by the Merwin brothers in 1995 and named after John Merwin’s daughter, Brooklyn Bedding is one of the original pioneers of the bed-in-a-box concept.

Unique Features

As a practical and quality accessory to their many state-of-the-art comfort mattresses, the Brooklyn Bedding luxury cooling mattress protector is snugly fitting, water resistant, and hypoallergenic.

Made of soft, smooth, high-tech PE fibers, this luxury mattress protector is cool to the touch to give you a fresh, airy sleep every time. Plus, it’s machine washable, making it easy to wash and care for.

Pricing and Promos

• Queen size: $96.75
• 30-day return policy
• 3-year warranty

Customer Support Info

Brooklyn Bedding has live chat customer service reps available onsite, or you can call 623-624-1222.

>>Get the Brooklyn Bedding Luxury Cooling Mattress Protector

2. Helix GlacioTex Mattress Protector – Best Breathable Mattress Protector

Overview

Known for their in-depth questionnaire to help match customers with the right sleep for their needs, Helix was established in New York City in 2015 by Jerry Lin, Adam Tishman, and Kristian von Rickenbach.

Unique Features

Featuring a cool-to-the-touch design with high thermal conductivity, this GlacioTex mattress protector pulls heat away from your body so you’ll sleep cool and comfy all night.

Offering 100% waterproof protection to guard against spills and stains, this protector is a 50/50 blend of polyester and polyethylene that is hypoallergenic and guards against bacteria and dust mites.

Pricing and Promos

• Queen size: $234 including free shipping
• 30-night sleep trial

Customer Support Info

The typical response time to chat live with a Helix representative is 3-5 minutes, or you can call at 831-777-5976.

>>Buy the Helix GlacioTex Mattress Protector

3. Nolah GlacioTex Cooling Mattress Protector – Best Cooling Mattress Protector

Overview

Founded in 2016 by Daniel Galle and Anna Hjoellund, the mission of Nolah has been to change the health and wellness of the average American by focusing on good sleep.

Unique Features

As the perfect solution for hot sleepers, this cooling mattress pad from Nolah offers high thermal activity fibers that remove body heat so you’ll always sleep cool. It’s also waterproof, hypoallergenic, and tough enough to handle anything, including spills, accidents, bacteria, dust mites, and more.

Pricing and Promos

• Queen size: $136 with free shipping
• 1-year warranty

Customer Support Info

Customer support can be reached via live chat on-site or by phone at 866-403-6615.

>>Buy the Nolah GlacioTex Cooling Mattress Protector

4. PlushBeds Organic Mattress Protector – Best Mattress Protector for Hot Sleepers

Overview

Founded in 2008 by Michael Hughes, PlushBeds is known for using natural, organic, and sustainable materials in all of their mattresses and sleep products.

Unique Features

This organic mattress protector is made with GOTS-certified organic cotton, making it soft, smooth, and eminently breathable. It fits any mattress thickness from 6”- 15” and offers a non-toxic waterproof solution that’s machine washable for easy care.

In addition, it is free of all VOCs and does not leach toxins or any off-gassing chemicals, making it completely odor-free.

Pricing and Promos

• Queen size: $149 with free shipping
• 3-year warranty

Customer Support Info

PlushBeds representatives can be reached 7 days a week from 9 am – 11 pm EST by phoning toll-free at 888-286-3404.

>>Explore PlushBeds Organic Mattress Protector benefits

5. Leesa Waterproof Mattress Protector – Best Waterproof Mattress Protector

Overview

Founded on the egalitarian belief that everyone deserves a better night’s sleep, Leesa was established in Virginia Beach, Virginia, in 2014 by David Wolfe and Jamie Diamonstein.

Unique Features

Made of lightweight performance fabric that provides 5-sided protection that you’ll hardly know is there, this waterproof mattress protector is both breathable and easy to maintain.

It will wrap around your mattress as snuggly as a fitted sheet, plus it will cover any mattress from 8”- 21” deep. It’s also hypoallergenic, meaning it not only protects against spills but bed bugs and dust mites as well.

Pricing and Promos

• Queen size: $66 with free shipping in the US
• 30-day risk-free trial
• 1-year limited warranty

Customer Support Info

Leesa customer service is available for live chat during normal business hours and by phone toll-free at 1-844-335-3372.

>>Buy the Leesa Waterproof Mattress Protector

6. Awara Organic Mattress Protector – Best Organic Mattress Protector

Overview

Established in 2017, Awara has set the lofty goal of promising to all its customers the best sleep of their lives, the way nature intended. That means all natural materials and mattress mechanics that are designed to help you sleep soundly and ergonomically.

Unique Features

Made from 100% organic cotton, this quality mattress protector is designed to be a light, airy, cool sleeping, and comfortable shield against spills, kids, and pets.

It is 100% waterproof, easily washable, and dryer-proof. It is also constructed with a no-slip design. Unlike other mattress protectors that can cause your sheets to slide around, this protector is designed to feel seamless underneath your mattress so you’ll forget it’s even there.

Pricing and Promos

• Queen size: $119 with free shipping
• Free 50-day returns

Customer Support Info

The Awara support team is available 7 days a week via chat, or you can call at 855-580-1382.

>>Buy the Awara Organic Mattress Protector

7. Nectar Waterproof Tencel Mattress Protector – Best Mattress Protector for Bedwetting

Overview

Launched in 2017 to provide customers with high-quality and high-performing mattresses at a reasonable price, Nectar is one of the most respected direct-to-consumer mattress companies online.

Unique Features

If you have a small child who likes to jump in bed with you when they’re scared or a cat who likes to make statements, this 100% waterproof Tencel mattress protector is for you.

Made with natural cotton and having an extra quilted cover for comfort along with sleek lines, this mattress protector stays put, doesn’t slip or slide, and is unnoticeable under your sheets.

Pricing and Promos

• Queen size: $149 plus free shipping
• 30-day home trial
• 1-year warranty

Customer Support Info

The Nectar support team is available 7 days a week via chat or call at 888-863-2827.

>>Get the Nectar Waterproof Tencel Mattress Protector

8. DreamCloud Waterproof Mattress Protector – Best Mattress Protector for Bed Bugs

Overview

Established in 2018 by the Resident Home company, DreamCloud is a DTC mattress maker that is committed to providing customers with quality bedding products that are durable and budget-friendly.

Unique Features

If you’re looking for a durable, waterproof mattress protector that can also repel bed bugs, then the DreamCloud waterproof mattress protector can keep you effectively sealed against all your worst nightmares.

Made with natural cotton and sporting a soft, quilted cover, this mattress protector provides a snug fit that will stay put and remain noiseless as you move around throughout the night.

Pricing and Promos

• Queen size: $149 with free shipping
• 30-night home trial
• 1-year warranty

Customer Support Info

The DreamCloud support team is available 7 days a week via chat or call at 833-237-3269.

>>Get the Waterproof Mattress Protector directly from DreamCloud

9. EcoTerra Tencel Eucalyptus Lyocell Mattress Protector – Best Lyocell Mattress Protector

Overview

Established in Los Angeles, CA in 2016, EcoTerra is committed to using only natural materials that are ethically sourced in all of their bedding products.

Unique Features

Crafted completely from organic eucalyptus lyocell, this mattress protector is the natural alternative to the more common plastic-based options available online.

This Tencel cover is also breathable and plush, and regulates the natural heat produced by your body to give you a comfy, cool sleep. It’s diamond-stitched to help keep its natural fill in place, and it doesn’t make those crinkling noises that manufactured plastic sheets make.

Pricing and Promos

• Queen size: $168

Customer Support Info

The support team at EcoTerra is available 7 days a week via chat or phone at 1-888-605-0096.

>>Buy the EcoTerra Tencel Eucalyptus Lyocell Mattress Protector

10. Birch Waterproof Mattress Protector – Affordable Mattress Protector

Overview

A sub-brand of Helix Sleep, Birch Living was established in 2019 and is known for sustainably sourced and eco-conscious mattress and bedding products.

Unique Features

Made with organic, Fair Trade-certified cotton, the Birch by Helix waterproof mattress protector is your best defense against spills, accidents, and dust mites.

With a skirted design that fits snugly around your mattress, its breathable internal layer and moisture-wicking cotton microfibers keep your mattress dry while letting you sleep cool and comfy.

Pricing and Promos

• Queen size: $112
• 30-night sleep trial
• 1-year warranty

Customer Support Info

The Birch support team is available 7 days a week via chat or call at 917-540-5525.

>>Get the Birch Waterproof Mattress Protector

What to Look for in the Best Mattress Protector

A good mattress protector can help keep your mattress nice and clean, and here’s what to think about when you’re picking the best one:

Material Types

Mattress protectors are made with several different materials. Depending on your needs, these can include breathable natural fibers such as cotton, linen, and bamboo, and waterproof synthetic blends like polyurethane and polyester.

Waterproof vs Water-Resistant

Most mattresses have internal materials that are highly absorbent and vulnerable to liquids. For the best mattress protection, waterproof is preferable to water-resistant.

Waterproof mattress protectors completely block liquids from penetrating the surface, while water-resistant ones can repel small spills but may not prevent larger amounts from seeping through.

Breathability and Cooling Features

Many people tend to sleep hot. Therefore, the best mattress protector should protect the mattress and keep the sleep surface cool. Naturally breathable materials like cotton and bamboo are better for this than denser synthetic materials like polyurethane. You should also pair it with a cooling mattress for effective results.

Allergy and Dust Mite Protection

Having a hypoallergenic mattress cover that doesn’t allow hair, dust, and dust mites to accumulate will provide a cleaner sleep surface and help to reduce allergic symptoms.

A study on anti-allergic mattress covers used by patients with asthma and dust mite allergy showed that using them led to significant reductions in dust mite concentrations in carpet-free bedrooms.

Noise and Feel

Synthetic mattress covers made of materials like polyester can tend to crinkle and make noise underneath the sheets when a sleeper moves around. In addition, synthetic covers also don’t feel as soft and luxurious as cotton or bamboo mattress covers.

Ease of Cleaning and Maintenance

Whether you purchase a natural or synthetic cover, the best mattress cover in terms of convenience is one that is strong enough to be both machine washable and dryer safe.

A quality protector should also be durable enough to withstand regular laundering and even basic cleaning agents like baking soda or distilled white vinegar.

Fit and Compatibility

Because a mattress cover is placed directly over the mattress for effectiveness, yet under the sheets to allow you to enjoy the comforts the sheets provide, it’s crucial for it to fit precisely.

This is especially important for a memory foam mattress, as an ill-fitting protector can hinder its contouring properties and overall feel.

A precise fit is vital for all bed sizes, from a twin XL for a college dorm to a spacious California king in a master suite, ensuring seamless protection and comfort.

>>Get the Brooklyn Bedding Luxury Cooling Mattress Protector

Types of Mattress Protectors

Mattress protectors may reduce how often you replace your mattress. However, they come in different styles. Here are the key ones to consider:

Fitted Sheet Style

A fitted sheet style protector covers the mattress on 5 of 6 sides. The snugness and exactness of this style protector can guard the mattress more closely while also allowing a more comfortable sheet to be put on top of it.

Encasement Style

An encasement style mattress protector is one that usually zips closed and covers the mattress on all 6 sides. This type is the best mattress protector when it comes to dealing with dust mites and/or bed bugs.

Strap Style

This kind of protector is secured to the mattress using elastic straps that allow for a tight form fit. Typically, this type of protector only covers the top of the mattress, leaving the other sides exposed.

Cooling Protectors

Cooling mattress protectors are designed to provide comfort for hot sleepers by wicking away moisture, controlling their body temperature, and allowing for better surface air flow.

Organic/Natural Protectors

Organic and natural mattress protectors, crafted from materials like cotton, bamboo, and eucalyptus, are naturally hypoallergenic and promote superior airflow.

These qualities can significantly enhance comfort, especially for those seeking the best mattress topper for back pain. They offer a cooler, allergen-free sleep surface that can contribute to better spinal alignment and pressure relief.

Why Use a Mattress Protector?

There are two reasons to use a mattress protector. First, it will help to extend the life of your mattress by shielding it from dust, dirt, accidents, allergens, and vermin like dust mites and bed bugs. Second, your health will also benefit from having a cleaner and more protected mattress.

Beyond protectors, mattress pads can offer an additional layer of cooling comfort. For comprehensive protection, consider a full mattress encasement, and remember your pillows, too – a good pillow protector can make a difference. Some innovative bedding even incorporates soothing elements like aloe vera gel for an extra touch of coolness and comfort.

>>Get the Brooklyn Bedding Luxury Cooling Mattress Protector

Customer Testimonials

Let’s see what real people are saying about some of the popular brands of mattress protectors we reviewed.

Brooklyn Bedding

One buyer on the official site says they love their mattress cover and the cooling technology is the real deal, making it perfect for hot summer nights at the lake. Another user also felt their mattress cover was great, but that it was a bit too slippery and made their bedsheets slide off [1].

Helix

One satisfied customer on the official site gave the GlacioTex mattress protector the highest rating, saying they bought one for their daughter and she loves it. Another user on the official site was also quite enamored with their GlacioTex protector, saying it is a magic product that makes a world of difference. They just wish it could have shipped faster [2].

Nolah

This user on the official site was skeptical at first, but now they agree that their GlacioTex cover really does help them sleep cooler. Another reviewer agreed the cover is cooling, but also complained that it slips, resulting in too much sheet movement [3].

PlushBeds

On the official site, Cyn said their PlushBeds organic mattress protector was not only very cooling but soft, lightweight, washable, and easy to handle from washer to dryer. But Elizabeth was skeptical about the supposed breathability of their mattress protector, though they did like it so far [4].

Leesa

One user on the official site feels their Leesa mattress protector is quite cooling, and they can hardly feel it under the sheets. However, Jacqueline didn’t think it was very cooling and also didn’t like how it felt on their bed [5].

Awara

Judith said they love their organic mattress cover in their review on the official site. It’s excellent quality and an excellent fit. Jennifer said they had to remove their mattress cover because it made their bed considerably less comfortable to sleep on [6].

Nectar

This user on the official Nectar site has dogs, and they say they feel 100% confident and protected with their waterproof Tencel mattress protector. Another customer also loved their Nectar mattress protector, except it shrank after the first washing, and now it doesn’t fit their queen-size bed [7].

DreamCloud

In her review on the official site, Pamela absolutely loves her mattress cover. It’s easy to put on, and besides the protection also adds a bit of softness to the bed. Another customer on the site liked the comfort of their mattress cover, but they also complained about the thickness and that it took up too much room in the washer [8].

EcoTerra

There are currently no reviews available for this product.

Birch Living

A customer on the official site said the Birch Waterproof Mattress protector is everything they’ve ever wanted in a mattress protector, and they’re going to buy more in the future. However, another user was somewhat disappointed because their mattress protector wasn’t as soft as they had hoped for [9].

>>Get the Brooklyn Bedding Luxury Cooling Mattress Protector

Best Mattress Protector: FAQs

These are some of the questions that customers in search of the best mattress protector have been asking.

Are Waterproof Mattress Protectors Better Than Regular Ones?

Yes, waterproof mattress protectors are generally thought to be better, particularly against night sweats, spills, and stains. The best mattress pad cover with waterproof properties will also offer a stronger barrier against dust, allergens, and vermin and help to lengthen the life of your mattress.

How Do I Know if a Mattress Protector Is Truly Breathable?

For genuine breathability, prioritize natural materials like cotton or bamboo with GOTS or OEKO-TEX certifications. Some synthetic materials, like 3D air fabric, also offer waterproof breathability.

Will a Mattress Protector Change the Feel of My Mattress?

Not usually. Mattress protectors are solely designed to provide a thin layer of protection for the mattress against moisture, dust, and vermin. By doing so, they also play a crucial role in extending the lifespan of mattresses. They are not intended to contribute to comfort or change the feel of the mattress.

Can the Best Mattress Protector Help With Allergies and Dust Mites?

Yes, the best mattress protector will create a barrier that will not allow allergens or dust mites to attach to the mattress where they can live and breed.

How Often Should I Wash a Mattress Protector?

The general rule of thumb is that you should wash a mattress protector every 1 or 2 months, unless you have a spill, suffer from allergies, or have pets on the bed.

Conclusion

In most cases, a mattress is a big investment. If you want to keep yours in the best shape for as long as possible, then a mattress protector is a wise investment.

The best mattress protector will not only help to keep your sleep surface clean and dry, but it can also prevent allergens from growing as a result of things like mold, mildew, dust, and dust mites.

Hopefully, the list of the best mattress protectors we’ve provided, starting with the Brooklyn Bedding Luxury Cooling Mattress Protector, will educate you about what to look for and save you some money in the process.

Good luck.

>>Get the Brooklyn Bedding Luxury Cooling Mattress Protector